Adult Award-Winning AWB (Award-Winning-Books) 2015 Books Filipino Lit GB Challenges It's Monday What Are You Reading Mystereadventure Reading Themes

[Monday Reading] Adult Crime Novels in F. H. Batacan’s “Smaller and Smaller Circles” and Hawkins’ “The Girl on the Train”


It's Monday! What Are You Reading

Myra here.

It’s Monday, What are You Reading is a meme hosted by Jen from Teach Mentor Texts and Kellee and Ricki from Unleashing Readers (new host of Monday reading: Kathryn T at Book Date). Since two of our friends, Linda from Teacher Dance and Tara from A Teaching Life have been joining this meme for quite awhile now, we thought of joining this warm and inviting community.

Last Week’s Review and Miscellany Posts

We’re also inviting everyone to join our Award Winning Books Reading Challenge for 2015 (#AWBRead2015)! You still have a month left before the year ends to win book prizes.


Here is the sign up page and the November-December linky if you already have reviews up. One randomly-selected participant would receive a copy of The World of Norm: May Contain Nuts by Jonathan Meres courtesy of Pansing Books.


Click here to view my announcement post to learn more details.


I read these two novels months ago. My recollections of the details from the books are a tad hazy at this point, but regardless, I thought that it would still be good to share these titles for our current reading theme.

11800352_10206325196381678_1872650033951529719_nThe Girl On The Train

Writer: Paula Hawkins
Published by: Doubleday, 2015
Bought my own copy of the book.

This novel was my indulgence while I was traveling in London. I bought it while I was in Munich a week before my travel to the UK, and it was well worth the splurge. Since I very rarely review adult novels here at GatheringBooks, I thought I’d adopt a different approach, especially since Penguin has very kindly prepared a set of questions meant for book club discussion. I selected just a few questions to guide my meandering thoughts about the novel.

We all do it—actively watch life around us. In this way, with her own voyeuristic curiosity, Rachel Watson is not so unusual. What do you think accounts for this nosey, all-too-human impulse? Is it more extreme in Rachel than in the average person? What is so different about her?

I think some of the questions posted here go beyond me – particularly as to what accounts for this “all-too-human impulse” of “voyeuristic curiosity.” My researcher’s spirit compels me to check the literature to provide a more intelligent response – so I would most probably skip that one. As to what is different about Rachel, in general, one thing struck me really as I was reading the novel: this lady is suffering from depression. Mix in substance abuse, and you have recipe for murder/crime novel.

How would you have reacted if you’d seen what Rachel did from her train window—a pile of clothes—just before the rumored disappearance of Megan Hipwell? What might you or she have done differently?

Took this photo while I was in Birmingham on my way to London.
Took this photo while I was in Birmingham on my way to London.

Hah. If it were me, I would probably have not gotten involved. The most I would have done would be to alert the police officers about my nagging suspicion – talk to someone who knows a police officer, that kind of thing – rather than insert myself into the investigation just like what Rachel has done. However, I am not Rachel – with all her emotional turmoil, her feelings of listlessness, her direction-less life. The pile of clothes has given Rachel a sense of purpose – something that allowed her to go outside of her misery to focus on something she found fascinating – a mystery that needed solving. At one point, I also felt that she has blurred the boundaries between what is real and imaginary, which made her accounts a tad confusing.

Seemingly abandoned train station at the University of Worcester in Birmingham.
Seemingly abandoned train station at the University of Worcester in Birmingham.

In both Rachel Watson’s and Megan Hipwell’s marriages, deep secrets are kept from the husbands. Are these marriages unusual or even extreme in this way? Consider how many relationships rely on half-truths? Is it ever necessary or justifiable to lie to someone you love? How much is too much to hide from a partner?

These questions are borderline nosy, don’t you think? The book club discussion might turn into a group therapy session! Allow me to focus on what I remember dimly from the novel. I tried to like Megan Hipwell, she seemed like a decent enough person – the idealized version of Rachel Watson’s imagined life. I suppose that is the problem with images/projections/ideals – they rarely live up to people’s expectations. Truth be told, I was expecting something more life-altering from Megan’s past – an episode in her life which she holds responsible for her turning out the way she did – at least the way she explains it to her therapist. Yet it seemed to me more like the bad choices of a grieving young person – that ultimately she will have to live with and embrace as part of her so that she can move on from it. Yet instead of owning it, she continues to make deliberately bad choices citing her earlier traumatic past as her justification for her errant ways – demonstrating a total lack of responsibility and agency. Yes, there is judgment there somewhere, I suppose.

What about the lies the characters tell to themselves? In what ways is Rachel lying to herself? Do all people tell themselves lies to some degree in order to move on with their lives? Is what Rachel (or any of the other characters) is doing any different from that? How do her lies ultimately affect her and the people around her?

This is all I have to say about this:


A crucial question in The Girl on the Train is how much Rachel Watson can trust her own memory. How reliable are her observations? Yet since the relationship between truth and memory is often a slippery one, how objective or “true” can a memory, by definition, really be? Can memory lie? If so, what factors might influence it? Consider examples from the book.

This is what made the novel a page-turner for me – my desire to get at the different versions of the truth for me to paint a clear picture in my head about what exactly happened to Megan and to Rachel as well, despite the latter’s neediness. Most reviewers tend to liken the plot to that of Gone Girl which I read last year – and I can see the parallels, particularly with the unreliable narrators whose memories are dubious at best. However, in Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl, I remembered the female protagonist being quite the narcissist and self-satisfied with her own smarts (perfectly justified really since she pulled off such a brilliant criminal act), whereas in The Girl on the Train there was a great deal of self-loathing – both for Rachel and Megan.

Train tracks in Birmingham

I also remembered feeling sad for the characters as I was reading the novel – imagining myself in Rachel Watson’s head – it ain’t such a pretty place. I was glad when I finished reading the novel – there was that palpable feeling of relief.

Smaller and Smaller Circles11949538_10206430067043379_9130465109156852582_n

Writer: F. H. Batacan
Published by: Soho Press, Inc. 2015.
Bought my own copy of the book.

The Guardian named Smaller and Smaller Circles as one of the best recent crime fiction novels and I could understand why. Unlike The Girl on the Train which afforded me a feeling of dread each time I open the pages, it is with a kind of giddy anticipation that I go back to this novel every night before I go to bed. It’s similar to watching a riveting episode of Criminal Minds or CSI perhaps before retiring for the night. My book club (Saturday Night Out for Book Geeks) discussed this novel a few months back. In fact, our good friend, children’s book author David Seow shared his thoughts in his blog – he was also our gracious host that evening (thanks again, Dave for hosting and to your mum for the fab feast).

Saturday Night Out for Book Geeks! :)
Saturday Night Out for Book Geeks! 🙂

The setting of the novel is in the gritty metropolis of Manila (where I grew up). Add in a serial killer who mutilates young boys (undersized, famished street children) every time it rains, and hides the scarred bodies in smelly dump sites; then throw in two hot learned Jesuit priests who are trained in forensics to assist in the criminal investigation; then put in a backdrop of the staggering corruption and bureaucracy of law and justice in the Philippines – and you have a social commentary wrapped in a seemingly-unsolvable crime. I’ve often wondered about the phrase “compulsively-readable” each time I come across it in blurbs – but this is what describes the novel quite well. While I initially felt that it was borderline pretentious in the beginning with the quote from Nietzsche – I gradually realized that the author was setting up the entire world for the reader, building it brick by brick with little details – from the music (of course it has to be the hip R. E. M.) to the setting (yes, the setting is a character here as well) to the tiniest description of Father Gus Saenz, Father Jerome Lucero, and Director Lastimosa; and the continual foreshadowing as evidenced in the smaller and smaller circles found at the beginning of each section where the reader gets a feel of how the criminal’s mind unravels. This is truly a thoroughly engaging read that crime enthusiasts should definitely check out.

Currently Reading…

I finished reading two novels last week:

Maira Kalman’s And The Pursuit Of Happiness and Leigh Bardugo’s Six Of Crows. These are novels that I enjoyed tremendously and will be posting more detailed reviews about them soon, particularly the latter as it fits our current reading theme to a T.

This week, I plan to read the following titles:


I have been meaning to read this for the longest while – now I have the perfect excuse given our current reading theme: The Screaming Staircase by Jonathan Stroud.


And because I need to have a graphic novel fix every week: Calling Dr. Laura: A Graphic Memoir by Nicole J. Georges.


Smaller and Smaller Circles: Carlos Palanca Memorial Award for Novel in English

#AWBRead2015 Update: 100 (35)

19 comments on “[Monday Reading] Adult Crime Novels in F. H. Batacan’s “Smaller and Smaller Circles” and Hawkins’ “The Girl on the Train”

  1. I laughed about “Everyone lies” in your Girl On The Train thoughts. So true! I didn’t enjoy that book as much as some did, but it was interesting.

    Have a great week!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I loved when you said you had a ‘feeling of dread” whenever you picked up The Girl On The Train. I did too, but somehow managed to finish it. I wish there was time to read more mysteries. I just met Elisabeth George at my local Indie bookstore last week, & love her books, but just can’t find the time to keep up. Thanks, Myra.


  3. It’s fun seeing you and Linda post about Girl/Train today! I just bought another book with a similar title but it’s historical fiction! I’d love to get some “adult reading” in sometime!


  4. Great post, photos, and books.

    Thanks for sharing.

    ENJOY this week of reading.

    Silver’s Reviews
    My It’s Monday, What Are You Reading


  5. Great deconstruction of The Girl on the Train…loved the questions and your thoughts, as well as the train illustrations. I thoroughly enjoyed the book, and had a number of thoughts similar to yours. Thanks for sharing…and for visiting my blog.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. The Girl on the Train- I’ve seen it mentioned 3 times already this week. Jonathan Stroud’s series has been popular. Apparently there’s a novella for it as well.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. I agree. I liked Girl on a Train, but I find it uncomfortable to read about characters who you wish you could help instead of reading about them!


  8. Screaming Staircase– yeay! Loved that series. Lumberjanes… just didn’t get. Lots of interesting books.

    Liked by 1 person

  9. I have really enjoyed the Lockwood & Co series. I still have the most recent sitting on my bookshelf waiting to be read. Smaller and Smaller Circles sounds interesting, but I’m not really enthusiastic about The Girl On The Train since the reviews are so conflicted.

    Liked by 1 person

  10. I think I’ll probably put The Screaming Staircase on my must read in 2016 list. I’ve heard such good things and I’m a big fan of Stroud’s other novels!

    Liked by 1 person

  11. I know many people enjoyed The Girl on the Train but I don’t read a lot of thrillers so it didn’t call to me! However your analysis of the book is amazing and I love the everyone lies!


  12. I feel like the peer pressure to read The Girl on a Train is going to get to me! It looks so interesting. I also rarely review adult books, but there have been so many good ones this year! Thanks for sharing, and thanks for the pictures!


  13. I love your pictures! I’ve been wanting to read The Girl on the Train. I started Gone Girl and couldn’t finish it. I didn’t get far before I decided that I loathed every single character and didn’t want to spend one more minute of my time with them! I enjoyed Jonathan Stroud’s Bartimaeus series several years ago but I haven’t picked up any of his other books. I need to get around to that. Enjoy your week!


  14. I love all of your photos! 🙂
    I need to read Marvels as I loved Selznick’s other novels. He’s brilliant.

    Happy reading this week!


  15. Great photos and I liked reading your thoughts on The Girl on the Train!


  16. The Girl on the Train is on my list to read. Have a great week!


  17. Those alphabet books are adorable!

    I enjoyed your review of Girl on the Train. Great insights!


  18. Pingback: [Our 2015 In Books – Part One of Two] A GatheringBooks List of Outstanding Reads | Gathering Books

  19. Pingback: A Country Within One’s Consciousness in Mia Alvar’s “In The Country: Stories” – Gathering Books

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: