[Diverse Kidlit] Remembering Auschwitz through a picturebook and a graphic novel

Myra here.

What Is #DiverseKidLit?

Diverse Children’s Books is a book-sharing meme designed to promote the reading and writing of children’s books that feature diverse characters. This community embraces all kinds of diversity including (and certainly not limited to) diverse, inclusive, multicultural, and global books for children of all backgrounds.

We encourage everyone who shares to support this blogging community by visiting and leaving comments for at least three others. Please also consider following the hosts on at least one of their social media outlets. Spread the word using #diversekidlit and/or adding our button to your site and your diverse posts.

DiverseKidLit

We hope this community serves as a resource for parents, teachers, librarians, publishers, and authors! Our next linkup will be Saturday, October 7th and the first Saturday of each month.

Upcoming Theme

Themes are a suggestion only; all diverse book posts are welcome. If you’re interested, you can start planning now …

  • Our theme for October (7th) will be #ownvoices. The #ownvoices hashtag was created to draw attention to diverse authors and illustrators who are creating books that honor their own heritage and experiences. Please share your favorite titles or authors / illustrators with us!

Most Clicked Post from Last Time

The most-clicked post from the previous #diversekidlit was one I am sure we all could use: 19 Multicultural Children’s Books teaching Kindness & Empathy. This fabulous collection of picture books covers a wide range of cultures and topics including issues around immigration, acceptance, jealousy, and more. Thanks for sharing, Svenja!

We are concluding our Literatura Europa reading theme today, and as is our wont, we thought it would be good to share heavy-going themes, especially since it’s diverse kidlit day.


The Magician Of Auschwitz

Written byKathy Kacer Illustrated by: Gillian Newland
Published by: Second Story Press, 2014 Literary Awards: Ruth and Sylvia Schwartz Children’s Book Award for Children’s Picture Book (2015), Rocky Mountain Book Award Nominee (2016) ISBN: 1927583462 (ISBN13: 9781927583463)
Bought a copy of the book. Book photos taken by me. 

While I have had the privilege of visiting quite a number of concentration camps in Europe (Dachau in Germany, Mauthausen in Austria, and Terezin Ghetto in the Czech Republic), I know that at one point I will have to find my way to Auschwitz, reputed to be the deadliest concentration camp where hundreds of thousands were mercilessly killed.

And so it came as a pleasant surprise to me to discover a Holocaust-themed picturebook that offered a bit of lightheartedness: magic in Auschwitz. This book is inspired by the life story of Werner Reich who was only a boy when he was taken from his home and brought to Terezin then subsequently to Auschwitz. It features the fortuitous meeting between the young Werner and Herbert Levin, his bunkmate, a famous magician at the time, known as Nivelli the Magician.

The story reminded me a little bit of the award-winning-movie Life is Beautiful. There is the attempt to craft a momentary respite from the stark realities through invisible strings and shuffling cards. Yet it is also sobering as Levin articulated how his performance is not just a recreational pastime, there are real dangers, if for some reason or another he displeases or bores the officers who ask him to perform.

Yet despite this, it is heartening to read a story that shows how prisoners managed to free their spirits through little things like these inside the concentration camp. Teachers would also be happy to note how there is a four-page Afterword providing extensive details about The Nivellis and Werner’s life complete with actual photographs.

Auschwitz

Written and Illustrated byPascal Croci
Published by: Harry N. Abrams, Inc. 2003. Translated from the French. ISBN: 0810948311 (ISBN13: 9780810948310)
Bought a copy of the book. Book photos taken by me. 

This is one of those graphic novels that would leave you feeling a little more befuddled after you have read it. The story begins in former Yugoslavia in 1993 as a couple, Kazik and Cessia, finally talks about their experience in Auschwitz in 1944 – at roughly the same time when they are about to be executed in the Yugoslavian barracks, as they are accused of being traitors.

The timeline did not really work for me. I had to read the Afterword for me to ultimately make sense of what was happening to who. I believe the author’s intention was to show how history seems doomed to repeat itself (quite true, especially in light of what is currently happening in the world). Such misfortune that this couple experienced this kind of violent extermination twice in their lives.

There is something innately powerful with the black-and-white images, the medium that the artist chose to use, along with those sunken, petrified, haunted eyes that seem to follow the reader everywhere. I was more taken with the fragments, as the narrative jumps from one POV to the next, alongside way too many characters. What redeemed the story for me was the cry for meaning in the end, the attempt to make sense of the insensible through questions that simply can not be answered, particularly about where hatred comes from:

And how people can avoid an ultimately-senseless tragedy such as this from happening again (even as it continues to happen in way too many parts of the world, which the artist also acknowledged in his Afterword):

The artist also shared his own personal insights in the end, as well as his reasons for undertaking this project, and the many people he has interviewed and who reviewed his work. He even included some of the criticisms articulated by his sources about his art. To his credit, I feel that he has done his best to represent their experiences as sensitively as he could, despite some of the apparent inaccuracies, which he also indicated in the end.

For other children’s books about the Holocaust, check out this extensive list created by the University of Toronto libraries for more recommendations across primary, middle school, and secondary levels.

#DiverseKidLit is Hosted by:

Katie @ The Logonauts
Blog / Twitter / Facebook / Pinterest

Becky @ Franticmommmy
Blog / Twitter / Facebook / Pinterest / Instagram

Carolina @ La Clase de Sra. DuFault
Blog / Twitter / Facebook / Google+

Gauri @ Kitaab World
an online bookstore for South Asian children’s books, toys and games
Blog / Twitter / Facebook / Pinterest / Instagram

Gayle Swift, Author of ABC, Adoption & Me
Blog / Twitter / Facebook / Google+

Jane @ Rain City Librarian
Blog / Twitter / Instagram

Marjorie @ Mirrors Windows Doors
Blog / Twitter / Facebook / Pinterest

Mia @ Pragmatic Mom
Blog / Twitter / Facebook / Pinterest / Instagram

Myra @ Gathering Books
Blog / Twitter / Facebook

Shoumi Sen, Author of Toddler Diaries
Blog / Twitter / Facebook

Want to be notified when the next #diversekidlit linkup goes live? Click here to join the mailing list. Interested in joining as a host or an occasional co-host? Contact katie at thelogonauts.com.

(Never participated in a linkup before? Please click here for a more detailed step-by-step.)

Get #DiverseKidLit Recommendations on Pinterest!

Our Pinterest board highlights a wide range of amazing posts and resources for Diverse Children’s Books. Please consider following the board for even more great books!

Share Your Link Below

  1. I like The Magician of Auschwitz, but I haven’t looked at Croci’s Auschwitz yet, and maybe I will pass on it, given your comments. Thanks for your insightful review.

    Like

    Reply

  2. I read and review a lot of Second Story books, but somehow have missed “The Magician of Auschwitz.” It sounds like a compelling read. I try to read everything thing I can about the heroes that risked their lives saving Jews from the concentration camps. Nice choice!

    Like

    Reply

  3. What a heartbreakingly powerful collection of books – may we never forget.

    Like

    Reply

  4. This is a hard topic to portray in such a way that is appropriate for younger audiences, and it seems like the former book you reviewed is a good example of such. It is a shame the graphic novel was not organized well, however.

    Like

    Reply

  5. […] most-clicked post from the previous #diversekidlit was, apparently, my linkup post about Remembering Auschwitz through a picture book and a graphic novel. This post shares two powerful resources about the Holocaust in general, and Auschwitz […]

    Like

    Reply

  6. […] most-clicked post from the previous #diversekidlit was Myra’s linkup post about Remembering Auschwitz through a picture book and a graphic novel. This post shares two powerful resources about the Holocaust in general, and Auschwitz […]

    Like

    Reply

  7. […] most-clicked post from the previous #diversekidlit was Myra’s linkup post about Remembering Auschwitz through a picture book and a graphic novel. This post shares two powerful resources about the Holocaust in general, and Auschwitz […]

    Like

    Reply

  8. […] most-clicked post from the previous #diversekidlit was Myra’s linkup post about Remembering Auschwitz through a picture book and a graphic novel. This post shares two powerful resources about the Holocaust in general, and Auschwitz […]

    Like

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: