DiverseKidLit: A Saturday Meme – Amazing Girls in PictureBooks

Myra, Iphigene, and Fats here.

Diverse Children’s Books is a brand new book-sharing meme designed to promote the reading and writing of children’s books that feature diverse characters. This community embraces all kinds of diversity including (and certainly not limited to) diverse, inclusive, multicultural, and global books for children of all backgrounds.

DiverseKidLit

We encourage everyone who shares to support this blogging community by visiting and leaving comments for at least three others. Please also consider following the hosts on at least one of their social media outlets. Spread the word using #diversekidlit and/or adding our button to your site and your diverse posts.

Interested in joining as a host or an occasional co-host? Contact Katie at 1logonaut (gmail).

We hope this community will grow into a great resource for parents, teachers, librarians, publishers, and authors! Our next linkup will be Saturday, April 16th.

For today’s post, I am featuring these two picturebooks which show young girls who are able to go beyond people’s expectations of them and soar above their current life circumstances to be more.. to be their amazing selves.


IMG_0394

Amazing Grace: 25th Anniversary Edition

Written by: Mary Hoffman Illustrated by: Caroline Binch
Published byFrances Lincoln Children’s Books, 1991, ISBN: 0803710402 (ISBN13: 9780803710405)
Book borrowed from the Jurong West Public Library. Book photos taken by me. Book Awards: Kinderboekwinkelprijs (1993)

I have been late to the Amazing Grace party. I read the 25th Anniversary Edition published in 2015. From the first page, when I saw Grace’s conversation with her Nana, I knew it was going to be a special book:

IMG_0395

The art is so vivid, so life-like that the reader seems privy to a very private, intimate experience. Grace is quite the spirited young girl. Gifted with stories and the opportunity to immerse herself in various shades of characters with the aid of her vibrant imagination, she knew that she could be anyone she chooses to be:

IMG_0397

… up until the time when her classmates told her she cannot be Peter Pan in a play because she is a girl, and because she’s Black.***

IMG_0398

I have to remind myself that this was published back in 1991 – way before the advent of the “we need diverse books” campaign, and when issues such as these may have been considered taboo and deemed to be way too political or inflammatory to be articulated in a picturebook. Yet, here it is. Grace’s quiet resolve, unwavering determination, and unapologetic radiance – remain to this date.

IMG_0399

The 25th anniversary edition also includes inspiring Afterword messages written by Floella Benjamin (Trinidadian-British actress, author, television presenter, singer, businesswoman and politician) and LeVar Burton (American actor, director). For teachers who wish to use this in the classroom, here is a very detailed 47-paged downloadable PDF file from isites.harvard.edu that includes discussion questions and possible activities that teachers can explore.

*** Note: Since I put up this post, I was alerted by co-host Crystal Brunelle @ Reading Through Life how Amazing Grace has actually received a great deal of critique – especially the page I shared above of Grace pretending to be Hiawatha and Mowgli. The page was deemed insensitive as it portrays stereotypical ideations of what it means to be Native American. Obviously, I read the UK version which still contains the page I mentioned – apparently, the US version has since edited the book and deleted it. I have always emphasized the use of a critical multicultural analysis framework in examining/reading any text – and clearly this remains a highly polemical issue – and I have much to still learn and absorb and be mindful of as I navigate my way around these themes.


IMG_0400

The Song of Delphine

Written and Illustrated by: Kenneth Kraegel
Published by: Candlewick Press, 2015. ISBN: 0763670014 (ISBN13: 9780763670016)
Book borrowed from the Jurong West Public Library. Book photos taken by me. 

At a time when picturebooks dealing with servitude/slavery are being minutely scrutinized and found wanting (see A Birthday Cake for George Washington and A Fine Dessert), this picturebook published last year talks about a “lonesome servant girl” named Delphine who live “in the far reaches of the wild savannah.”

IMG_0401

While it is indicated that Delphine’s life is not easy, she found comfort in singing, her voice ringing true in the wilderness. Then one day, the young Princess Beatrice, about Delphine’s age, came to live at the palace.

IMG_0402

Princess Beatrice just lost her mother and was not in good terms with her stepmother. She was horrid, spiteful, and made life quite miserable for Delphine. It was again through her music that Delphine found some measure of escape – and this can be taken literally since the giraffes come to her window after listening to her beautiful voice, bringing her out “under the open sky.”

IMG_0404

While I did find Delphine to be quite passive, lacking in agency, and pretty much resigned to her fate and the injustices that she experienced from Princess Beatrice, it does highlight kindness, forgiveness, and friendship. The power difference between the two young girls remains stark even in the end – and perhaps this could be fodder for discussion among older children, but it did leave me with more questions than answers, and a sense of restlessness about how young Delphine was portrayed. Regardless, it is a book worth checking out.

diversekidlit-logo-200px

Hosted By:

Katie @ The Logonauts

Blog / Twitter / Facebook / Pinterest

Myra @ Gathering Books
Blog / Twitter / Facebook

Crystal @ Reading Through Life and co-blogger @ Rich in Color
Blog / Twitter / Google+

Carrie @ There’s a Book for That
Blog / Twitter

Mia @ Pragmatic Mom
Blog / Twitter / Facebook / Pinterest / Instagram

(Never participated in a linkup before? Please click here for a more detailed step-by-step.)

  1. These are two of my favorite books. Having a Diverse Kid Lit is such a wonderful idea and will hopefully inspire people to read more of the great books they see listed each month.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

  2. Your post and your thoughts and reflections here remind us of just how important it is to be thoughtful and aware of the images and stories we share with children – what messages are we sending? What stereotypes are highlighted? How do we have those conversations?

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

  3. Thanks for highlighting these books, and I appreciate your update too about renewed criticism. It reminds me of a conversation at NCTE where teachers were talking about why they use controversial books with kids – to open their eyes to thinking critically.

    So excited to have you as a host!

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

  4. So excited about this new meme, Myra! I shall be linking up too! Amazing Grace – a classic book that never gets old! Interesting comments about the criticism of this book. The Song of Delphine is new to me so I will add it to my list! Thanks, Myra!

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

  5. I’m looking forward to seeing the updated version of Amazing Grace here in the states. I love the text, but the depiction of Grace as Hiawatha is a big negative for me. I’m glad the publisher chose to omit that spread in the anniversary edition. I’ll be on the lookout for The Song of Delphine.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: