Books Fractured Fairytales Picture Book Challenge 2011 Picture Books PoC Reading Challenge 2011 Reading Themes South Asian Challenge 2011

A Fairly Weird Fairy Tale: Wingless by Paro Anand and Illustrated by Atanu Roy

Myra here.

I knew when I found this book in the Singapore Library Book Fair that it was one of those books that would speak to me – I was already taken by the subtitle: A Fairly Weird Fairy Tale – for some reason black and white quirky illustrations and equally strange narratives (or at least those which claim to be) appeal to me. While it is not technically a retelling of a tale that is already old and familiar to most of us, it is described by the author Paro Anand as a “modern fairy tale which looks at contemporary issues including how we look at people who are different from us” (source here).

An Angel Without Wings. The story begins with a Princess being born: the beautiful Princess Chutki to King Quicksilver and Queen Sparkling Gem. She was an ‘almost-perfect’ child except for the one thing that supposedly defines her being an angel: her wings (or should I say its absence).

Look at how exquisitely detailed the artwork is.

Naturally, this ‘aberration’ was met with fear and mourning – and what people do not understand they reject and treat unjustly. Here are some of the people’s reactions (and judgments) to Chutki’s being different:

“The King and Queen must have done something VERY bad to deserve a daughter like this.”

“The Kingdom of Angels is doomed. The end is in sight.”

“We must kill this freakish princess before she kills us.”

“She has brought Hell into Heaven. She must be punished.”

All these are familiar lines to most of us. We have heard this in one form/variation or another. Its being common and trite however does not make it right. More than anything, it makes me sad. Yet another way to deal with things we do not understand is to seek greater knowledge and ask people who may provide us with more information – hence, we get introduced to off-the-wall characters such as Nani Ma who is a thousand and three years old, Dadi Ma who happens to be two thousand years and 364 days old…

Dadi Ma and her glorious dripping flowing hair

… and one of my favorite characters in the narrative Zamroo of Zamroodpur. In his offer of help to the King, he introduced himself in this fashion:

One thousand years ago, when I was born with ‘W’-shaped wings instead of the standard ‘V’-shaped ones, your father, the King prevented the angels from cutting my wings off. He convinced the angels that W was a very write shape. For, after all you write Wings with a ‘W.’ They are Wings not Vings. That perhaps, this was the shape of wings to come. Of course he was just being very wise and witty, but through all this, the angels learned that they should try to understand someone or something which is different from them. Just because a person is not EXACTLY like you, does not mean that he is not a person. It just means that he’s a person who has some things or some wings that are different from you and other things that are the same.” (p. 10)

The reader is also taken through black rains and wild storm by a very helpful mynah bird, a family of cats as we see a babyless home meeting a homeless baby amidst dust, smoke, and fleas. The story is fast-paced, quick-witted, absolutely no dull moments in the repartee and exchanges. This is such a refreshingly beautiful book from authors and illustrators that I had no knowledge of until now that we are doing this fractured fairy tale theme. Truly a moving story that depicts how one does not need wings to fly and realize one’s inner truth and being.

Click on the image to be taken to the websource.

Illustrations with Rhythm and Movement. After much googling and websearching, I was able to find some information about cartoonist/illustrator Atanu Roy. Atanu is said to have illustrated more than a hundred books and has received various prizes including the Children’s Choice Award in 1989 (AWIC), the IBBY Honour List for Illustration in 2006 and various prizes at the Yomiuri Shimbun International Cartoon Contest in 1983, 1984, and 1986 (source here).

What I enjoy about Atanu’s art work is that there is a cartoon, graphic novel element to it and it is packed with such rich details one can literally get lost in just a single page. So the images are constantly moving, flying from one page to the next, and essentially filled with movement. Here are some of the photos I have taken to give you a glimpse into Atanu’s world:

The poor mynah bird
One of my favorite images from the book – so haunting
Our precious Wingless Princess

When One is Neither Here nor There. Another aspect that I enjoyed about the book is this constant struggle between being neither here nor there. I like how they summarize the narrative at the back of the book in this fashion:

As Chutki grows up, does she find out what her true origins are? Does she get rejected from where she belongs and accepted where she doesn’t?

I am always taken by this notion of being in-transit: of finding one’s self neither here nor there, being caught-in-between-worlds. Princess Chutki’s realization of her inner being also borders on the story being somewhat like a folktale – which once again blurs the boundaries between fairy tales, folk tales, and legends – narratives of how things came into existence. The power of the story lies in the struggle to find wholeness and acceptance from within you and the people around you, and the ultimate complexity of being disassembled in unity – and finding meaning and integrity in the fragments of who you are.

Click on the image to be taken to the websource.

Paro Anand has written 18 books for children and young adults, which also include plays, novels and short stories. Her official website also noted that  she headed the National Centre for Children’s Literature, The National Book Trust, India, which is the apex body for children’s literature in India. She has also helped in setting up libraries and Readers’ Clubs in rural India and conducted training programs on the use of literature.

Paro Anand has likewise been given a number of recognition for her contribution to children’s literature by The Russian Centre for Science and Culture. Dr. Kalam, the President of India, honored her for her writings on Republic Day, 2007 and has represented the country at various forums internationally, including UK and France (source here).

PictureBook Challenge Update: 95 of 120

PoC Reading Challenge Update: 40 (25)

South Asian Challenge Update: 4 of 7

Wingless: A Fairly Weird Fairy Tale by Paro Anand with equally weird illustrations by Atanu Roy. IndiaInk, New Delhi, India, 2003. Bought my own copy of the book.

Myra is a Teacher Educator and a registered clinical psychologist based in Al Ain, United Arab Emirates. Prior to moving to the Middle East, she lived for eleven years in Singapore serving as a teacher educator. She has edited five books on rediscovering children’s literature in Asia (with a focus on the Philippines, Malaysia, India, China, Japan) as part of the proceedings for the Asian Festival of Children’s Content where she served as the Chair of the Programme Committee for the Asian Children’s Writers and Illustrators Conference from 2011 until 2019. While she is an academic by day, she is a closet poet and a book hunter at heart. When she is not reading or writing about books or planning her next reads, she is hoping desperately to smash that shuttlecock to smithereens because Badminton Is Life (still looking for badminton courts here at UAE - suggestions are most welcome).

20 comments on “A Fairly Weird Fairy Tale: Wingless by Paro Anand and Illustrated by Atanu Roy

  1. Love that final “Why me?” illustration and also the clearly evocative Indian feel with a universal message of accepting differences, others’ and one’s own. The message is layered and children and adults are going to definitely be appreciating this at different levels. My mind is so caught up in marketing and publishing at the moment, I confess I was thinking that this would be a hard sell to a Western publisher at the moment, I assume it was published on the subcontinent?


    • Hi Joanna, that’s an astute observation. It’s published by IndiaInk Publishing Company in New Delhi. I suppose all these ruminations may have been influenced by the SCBWI Summer Conference in LA? Haha. I hope I can get to attend sometime soon.


  2. Indeed. a) they don’t want fairy tales and b) text to be kept to a minimum, preferably between 250 and 600 words! Definitely try and get to a conference – well worth the investment. I hope to go to LA again next summer (NY in Jan is impossible with my schedule), maybe a chance to meet? 🙂


    • Oh dear, that is Sad. Not wanting fairy tales. What a tragedy. I am currently finishing ‘My mother she killed me, my father he ate me’ and the foreword written by Kate Bernheimer has intimated as much. =(

      How about your coming over for the Asian Festival of Children’s Content in May 2012??? We have a lot of international guests coming over – and it’d be good for you to have a taste of Asia once in a while. Food is great, I promise. If I don’t make it in LA for summer, we have to see whether we can see each other in Europe – I’m targeting Finland for 2012. Not sure yet when. Will let you know as soon as I have details firmed up. But that’d be exciting.


  3. What a beautiful book. I love the illustrations. Great find!


  4. This title spike to me, too! I love the review you have given of this book- it makes me want to read it even more. I just added it to my must read list!


  5. Pingback: Carnival of Children’s Literature and Round-up for August |

  6. would love to read this..thanks for this find..the illustrations are wonderful and chutki – i am going to love her


  7. Pingback: Creating Content(ment) for Children, International Seminar and Exhibition, IDC, IIT Mumbai India |

  8. Pingback: The 2011 Reading Challenge Round Up |

  9. Pingback: List of Fractured Fairy Tales – A Gathering Books Recommendation |

  10. Paro Anand

    Hi! This is Paro Anand. Just chances upon this. Thanks so much for your very insightful and sensitive review. I will be in Singapore for the ‘Words Go Round’ children’s literature event in February-March next year and will be speaking about ‘Wingless..’ it might be a wonderful opportunity to connect


  11. Atanu Roy

    Can you beat this folks? I have just seen this site for the first time and the real super comments and observations by you all. Thank you ever so much. Wingless was created on a very tight budget by an enormously talented and committed publisher and an equally great writer – Paro. It was one of those very rare projects where I am given a free hand throughout! The illustrations are a mix of caricature/cartoon and some serious realistic style. All the illustrations are drawn same size as printed in the book.


  12. Pingback: South Asian Review Database - “A” - S Krishna's Books

  13. Pingback: Atanu Roy’s Artwork in The Puffin Book of Magical Indian Myths |

  14. Pingback: Of summers, reading and a book list with Tanu Shree Singh | polkacoffee

  15. Pingback: Scraggly, Sniggering, Never Prim: Drawing the Indian Child in the Indian Children's Book

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: