Award-Winning Books GB Challenges Whodunit Reading Challenge Young Adult (YA) Literature

The Book Without Words: A Fable of Medieval Magic by Avi

While technically this book has words and does not necessarily fit into our Wordless Picture Book bimonthly theme last March/April, I just could not resist including this book which called out to me from the library shelves. I decided to include this in our Whodunit Database instead because it has multiple deaths, shrouds of secrecy, and yes the classic “who is good/who is evil” conundrum among the characters.

“It was in the year 1046, on a cold winter’s night, when a fog, thick as wool and dank as a dead man’s hand, crept up from the River Scrogg into the ancient town of Fulworth. The fog settled like an icy shroud over the town, filling the mud-clogged streets and crooked lanes from Westgate to Bishopsgate, from Three Rats Quay upon the decaying river banks to Saint Osyth’s Cathedral by the city center. It clung to the crumbling city walls. It heightened the stench of rotten hay and offal, of vinegary wine and rancid ale. It muffled the sound of pealing church bells calling the weary faithful to apprehensive prayers.”

And so began The Book Without Words. This description alone is sufficient to establish the setting and the general whodunit feel of the book.  I have googled some of the places as indicated by Avi in his introduction but I was only able to find a picture of Saint Osyth’s Cathedral.

St. Osyth’s Cathedral. Click on the image to be taken to the websource.

The website indicated that the Church has stood on the site for at least 900 years. It was said to have been built in 1118 by Bishop Belmeis – not 1046 as depicted by Avi in the book. Of course Avi may have used creative license in his writing or may have envisioned a totally different church as compared to this one which is still presently standing somewhere in the UK.

Wordless Magic Book, Stones of Life, and a Green Eyed Boy Burning with Earthly Desire. This lovely book has all the ingredients (perfect alchemical mixture) to a fast-paced YA read with a handful of aphorisms and ponderables to consider in a quiet evening, alone. Issues concerning life and death, immortality, reality of magic, truths concealed in fables would most likely arise.

Imagine an ancient book filled with blank parchment which contains elusive truths that are revealed only to a green-eyed being who is desperate enough to read the shimmering secrets found in the fragile, near-crumbling pages. Add to that the stones of life (the infamous philosopher’s stone which has been the subject of so many bestselling books, Harry Potter being one of them), a talking raven, a simple-minded thirteen year old servant, a mad alchemist, a troubled monk, a power hungry Reeve, a greedy apothecary, and a young boy in need of love – and you have a timeless classic in your hands.

St. Osyth Priory – the Gatehouse. Click on the image to be taken to the websource.

The wordless magic book contains all the secrets to immortality and the Holy Grail to creating gold out of nothing. The pages, however, remain blank until a certain green-eyed boy (or girl) would be able to decipher its secrets with a heart filled with desperate longing. However, the revelations come with a prize: “It gives what is desired, but the desire consumes the taker” (p. 140) – the phrase actually reminds me of the oft-quoted: Be careful what you wish for, you just might get it; A bargain with the devil – Gain the World, Lose thine Soul. As explained by the monk who wishes to destroy the book:

“It contains all the evil magic of Northumbria. Whereas it can only be used in these Northumbrian precincts, its magic gives what is desired, even as the desire consumes the magician… Since such evil can never be entirely destroyed, it must be kept from those who might misuse it.” (p. 95) 

Northumbria trails – click on the image to be taken to the websource.

The science and art of alchemy and wizardry. In this book, Avi speaks of four stones which need to be consumed in a specific order: (1) Life, (2) Thoughts, (3) Magic and (4) Time. From that alone, one can make inferences and educated guesses as to why it should be taken in this order. And as the narrative unfolds, the reader is able to sift out the meaning and its seemingly irreversible nature.

I also enjoyed how Avi describes the art of making potions:

“With his left hand, he reached into a round box and removed a perfect cube of white clay. With his right hand, he kneaded the clay until it became as soft as the nape of a newborn’s neck. With his left hand, he placed the clay at the bottom of the pot – in its exact center.

Weak heart fluttering with excitement, Thorston used his right hand to pour a flagon of water over the clay. The water was holy water siphoned secretly from the cathedral’s baptismal font, then tinted pink with a drop of his own blood.

Taking the items from his hip purse, the old man rapidly added to the mix; bits of shredded gargoyle ears, chimera crumbs, scales from a fire-lizard’s tail, two dozen white spider legs, thirteen and a half nightshade leaves, sixteen hairs from the tip of a Manx cat’s tail, plus six white pearls of dried unicorn tears. He also dropped in the blackest of the raven’s black feathers.” (p. 3)

I just had to include that – my goodness, where does he find all these in his consciousness? Or maybe it is an altered state of consciousness/parallel planes of awareness that bring about this array of images in his head, I really don’t know. But it’s awe-inspiring.

Epigrams, Word play and Teacher Resources. This website shows how Avi’s book was used by a Mr. Moshe to generate a “setting discussion” with his students (click here to be taken to his site and the questions he raised to his class). I also was not surprised to discover that this book has garnered quite a number of awards (source here):

Children’s Book-of-the-Month selection 
Review, Publishers Weekly, 2005
Booksense Children’s Picks for Fall 2005
New York Public Library Books for the Teen Age, 2005
Bank Street Best Children’s Books of the Year List, 2006

This downloadable pdf link created by Ellen Everett Myrick from is also an amazing resource that details possible discussion questions, various activities involving proverbs and fables, a glossary of terms, and a detailed interview with the author himself!

I believe that the strength of this book lies in Avi’s ingenious way of playing with words that is just plain brilliant. He writes in epigrams as voiced through his characters – there are philosophical twists that would not even be perceived as annoying and pedantic – but whimsical, humorous, and authentic. Here are some of them:

A fool is the first to think himself wise but last to know it isn’t so – Odo (p. 27)

‘When you are older,’ said Odo, ‘you’ll learn that farce is but tragedy in excess.’ – p. 83 

“Odo,” she said, “do you think magic is nothing but life in haste?” The bird shook his head. “More likely it’s the other way around: life being the slowest magic.” (p. 164) 

This one though is my personal favorite and I believe captures the essence of the entire book with the main character’s quest for immortality:

“Living is my life. Have you any idea how difficult it has been to preserve myself for this moment? To avoid accidents, illness, and violence. Think how hard it is to keep oneself from death!”

“To what purpose, Master?” said Odo.

“To begin my whole life again,” said Thorston. “I’ve outwitted death.” 

“Ah, Master,” said the bird with a shake of his head, “what good was that life, if, by avoiding death, you didn’t live.” (p. 179)

About Avi. Iphigene (or Mary as she was named here previously – we changed it so that there’d be no confusion about our names which are anagrams) has done a review of Avi’s Strange Happenings here. And she has also given a detailed description of the author Avi in her post. If you wish to know more about the author, click here to be taken to his official website.

The Book without Words: A Fable of Medieval Magic by Avi. Hyperion Publishing, 2005. Book borrowed from the community library.

Myra is a Teacher Educator and a registered clinical psychologist based in Al Ain, United Arab Emirates. Prior to moving to the Middle East, she lived for eleven years in Singapore serving as a teacher educator. She has edited five books on rediscovering children’s literature in Asia (with a focus on the Philippines, Malaysia, India, China, Japan) as part of the proceedings for the Asian Festival of Children’s Content where she served as the Chair of the Programme Committee for the Asian Children’s Writers and Illustrators Conference from 2011 until 2019. While she is an academic by day, she is a closet poet and a book hunter at heart. When she is not reading or writing about books or planning her next reads, she is hoping desperately to smash that shuttlecock to smithereens because Badminton Is Life (still looking for badminton courts here at UAE - suggestions are most welcome).

5 comments on “The Book Without Words: A Fable of Medieval Magic by Avi

  1. WOW! Lovely, I enjoyed your review, my interest is certainly peaked.

    Thanks for sharing, Sammy


  2. This sounds eerily evocative and wonderfully Medieval. From some of your quotes there seem to be some real profound nuggets of truth woven into the story also. What an awesome hook that first sentence is! Avi has me entwined already there. I know I would love this, Myra. Thank you.


    • The quotes are beautiful and would undoubtedly strike a chord in every reader, notwithstanding one’s present realities. And yes I was hooked too. =) I meant to write a review of Murder at Midnight also by Avi – but alas, life and more conferences (presently attending one right now on ‘visual cultures, modernity, and society) do get in the way. Haha. =)


  3. Pingback: Saying Goodbye to the First Half of the Year, Our June Round-Up |

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: