Award-Winning Black History Month 2011 Books Picture Book Challenge 2011 Picture Books PoC Reading Challenge 2011

On Folktales and Faces of Good and Evil: The Talking Eggs by Robert D. San Souci and Pictures by Jerry Pinkney

GatheringBooks' Black History Month Special runs from February 18-25, 2011. Click on the image to be taken to the websource

We were a little ambitious when we found out about Black History Month (BHM) and while we planned on doing an 8-day feature, we (at least Fats and myself who have access to glorious libraries) did a book-borrowing frenzy. Unfortunately, life does get in the way and we can only do so much despite our best intentions. While there are still lovely picture books piled high on my wobbly bookshelf, I choose this Creole-adapted folktale as one of my books for our BHM special.

The title captured my attention

Clear Lines of Good and Bad – Rose and Blanche. One of the things that attracted me to this book is that it reminded me of fairy tales of old where things make simple sense: good and bad are clearly defined and delineated. One is aware of the order of the universe, there are no gray areas. And the evil ones always get their comeuppance in the end.

The mean Rose and her mother could be seen idling their time away while Blanche does all the work for them

The description of the two girls in this adapted folktale happen to be just that – the antagonist and the protagonist are clearly evident at the onset:

Rose, the older sister, was cross and mean and didn’t know beans from birds’ eggs. Blanche was sweet and kind and sharp as forty crickets. But their mother liked Rose the best, because they were alike as two peas in a pod – bad-tempered, sharp-tongued, and always putting on airs.

The first few pages also reminded me of the fairy stories that I grew up with: Cinderella and her stepsisters, Snow White and the cruel stepmother, and Beauty and her frivolous siblings (at least the one in the fairy tale not the Disney version).

Cinderella and the cruel stepsisters and the horrid stepmother - click on the image to be taken to the websource

The mother made Blanche do all the work around the place. She had to iron the clothes each morning using an old iron filled with hot coals, chop cotton in the afternoon, and string the beans for supper. While she’d be doing these chores, her mama and sister would sit side by side in rocking chairs on the shady porch, fanning themselves and talking foolishness about getting rich and moving to the city, where they could go to fancy balls wearing trail-train dresses and lots of jewels.

Kindness of Strangers. The events take on a magical edge when Blanche helped out an old woman who nearly had a heat stroke and was in dire need of water.

Blanche and the Old Woman Deep in the woods

“Thank you, child,” said the old woman when she’d taken swallow after swallow of water. “You got a spirit of do-right in your soul. God is gonna bless you.”

I deliberately included that phrase since one could feel that distinct sense of language unique to this piece of work – and the book having its own authentic voice. The folk tale element – where it was important to show good will to people who are in need – is likewise clearly evident.

House of Oddities and Goodness that Glistens. It was the cruelty and utter unfairness of Blanche’s mother and sister that drove her straight into the kind arms of the same old woman whom she helped earlier that day. After promising not to laugh at anything she would see regardless of how strange it may appear, the old woman “wrapped in a raggedy black shawl” offered shelter and rest for Blanche’s tired and weary soul, opening her house of oddities (complete with a two headed cow with corkscrews for horns; multi-colored chickens running about with one leg, sometimes three, four or even more; and men and lady rabbits hopping about, playing the banjo and doing a cakewalk) to this girl with a “do-right in her soul.”

The rabbits doing a square dance, a Virginia reel and yes, a cakewalk too! Their suits remind me of the rabbit in Alice in Wonderland, yes, the one who's always late.

Never mind that the old lady removes her own head and lays it down on her knees like a pumpkin as she braids her own hair, or that an old beef bone can magically turn into a bubbling, thick stew; or that a single grain of rice could fill an empty pot to overflowing -this book has that kind of surreal yet achingly familiar quality of storytelling the way it should be told, and so soo rich with beautiful illustrations and lyrical text.

All that glitters is not… goOd. One clear message that is shared in this book is that things are more than what they appear on the outside. While absolutes are provided (good/evil – cruel/kindness dichotomy), one is invited to see beyond the surface and dig for truth within. As a present for Blanche’s kindness, the old woman shared her “talking eggs” with the young girl:

Blanche taking the plain eggs over the jewel-encrusted ones

Go out to the chicken house. Any eggs that say, ‘Take me,’ you go ahead and take. But if you hear any say, ‘Don’t take me,’ you leave them be. When you get near home, throw those eggs one after another over your left shoulder so they break in the road behind you. Then you’ll get a surprise.

While seemingly-simple, the choice could actually be kind of difficult since it was the plain eggs who said “Take me!” while the gold, silver, and jeweled eggs cried out “Don’t take me!” While Blanche wished that she could take just one gold egg with her, she knew better than to do what should not be done.

Rose and her equally cruel mother being chased by ugly things that come out of beautiful, jewel-encrusted eggs

When she got home, her sister Rose naturally felt envious after seeing the beautiful things that Blanche took home with her from the plain talking eggs that spilled out: “diamonds and rubies, now gold and silver coins, now pretty silk dresses and dainty satin shoes” and even a handsome carriage with a fine brown-and-white pony! Whether or not Rose would also get the same lovely trinkets that Blanche got from the eggs, I shall leave you to discover for yourself.

The play in words given Rose and Blanche’s names is likewise in keeping with this theme of “all that glitters…” – the name Rose suggests beauty, delicacy, and that fragile quality to it; Blanche on the other hand sounds plain, simple, and totally without guile or charm. We see clearly in the story how things can be so completely different from how things may be packaged on the outside.

Teacher Resources. When I surfed the net, I found quite a number of helpful resources that would assist educators in introducing this book to the class. Here in LessonsPlanPage, one would be able to see lesson activities and discussion questions that can be used in class with materials that can be used for a possible classroom workshop. In this Study Guide created by Jill Ramsey from Tennessee Technological University, educators have the option to use graphic organizers, create their own magical eggs, and some letter-writing activities that can be done given this book.

Robert D. San Souci is the author of so many award-winning picture books for children and he has also written books for adults. A Californian native, San Souci graduated from St. Mary’s College and currently lives in Albany. He has also collaborated with his brother Daniel San Souci who happens to be a very talented illustrator who has also done quite a number of books. Click here to be taken to Robert’s official website.

I was first introduced to the beautiful artwork of Jerry Pinkney in the picture book God Bless the Child (which we featured here) and I’ve been a fan ever since. A frequent recipient of the Caldecott Honor, he has illustrated many award-winning picture books, including the much honored Patchwork Quilt (which I hope to find and read very soon).

PictureBook Reading Challenge Update: 23 of 72

PoC Reading Challenge Update: 16 of 25


Myra is a Teacher Educator and a registered clinical psychologist based in Al Ain, United Arab Emirates. Prior to moving to the Middle East, she lived for eleven years in Singapore serving as a teacher educator. She has edited five books on rediscovering children’s literature in Asia (with a focus on the Philippines, Malaysia, India, China, Japan) as part of the proceedings for the Asian Festival of Children’s Content where she served as the Chair of the Programme Committee for the Asian Children’s Writers and Illustrators Conference from 2011 until 2019. While she is an academic by day, she is a closet poet and a book hunter at heart. When she is not reading or writing about books or planning her next reads, she is hoping desperately to smash that shuttlecock to smithereens because Badminton Is Life (still looking for badminton courts here at UAE - suggestions are most welcome).

6 comments on “On Folktales and Faces of Good and Evil: The Talking Eggs by Robert D. San Souci and Pictures by Jerry Pinkney

  1. Wow! This book sounds and looks amazing– love the illustrations! Folktales are always one of my faves– I used to read all the anthologies of folktales I could find as a kid. I recognise many familiar themes in this one– I’ll keep an eye out for it.

    Visiting from the picture book challenge– glad to have found your blog!


    • myragarcesbacsal

      Hi Lesa, thank you for visiting. Please feel free to explore the site. Jerry Pinkney books are always amazing, it’s such a shame we weren’t able to find the time to review all of his books for our Black History Month special. =) Will visit your site soon.


  2. Pingback: February Round-Up: Reading through the Month of Love and Announcement of 1st batch of Whodunit Winners |

  3. my little brother would make me tell him this story every night before going to bed. when we were young we had no idea what this book really meant now that i read it again. All time favorite


  4. Pingback: Black History Month 2012 «

  5. Pingback: The Orphan: A Cinderella Story from Greece – Gathering Books

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: